All The Lonely People

Chantal Akerman’s early features have one aspect in common: all are suffused with loneliness. In her first fiction feature, Je Tu Il Elle (1974), a character wanders between lovers old and new but is always confused as to what she really wants, only really content in isolation. In Jeanne Dielman, 23 Commerce Quay, 1080 Brussels (1975), we follow a woman trapped in the monotony of a mysteriously empty everyday life with her son. Even in her documentaries, Akerman possessed a vagabond approach haunted by solitude; her films acting as messages in a bottle, films such as New from Home (1977), a city poem narrated by letters received from her own mother.

The 1970s peak for Akerman with her loneliest and most beautifully distanced of films, Les Rendez-vous d’Anna (1978). More so than her previous films up to that point, Akerman affirms the melancholy of constant travel through her most ambitious set of visual scenarios.

Les Rendez-vous d’Anna follows film director Anna (Aurore Clément) as she travels around Europe attending screenings of her films. On her way, she meets a man in Germany, Heinrich (Helmut Griem), who she initially takes back to her hotel to sleep with before being unable to go through with it. She instead opts to meet his family the next day and hear the story of his sad life.

She then travels again, meeting a friend of her mother’s and, eventually, her mother herself (Lea Massari) in whom she confides her first experience of intimacy with another woman. Finally, travelling back to her home city, she goes to a hotel with an ex lover (Jean-Pierre Cassel) before ultimately ending up alone in her flat listening to answer-phone messages.

Journey

Akerman herself was a traveller, venturing around the world with only a vague sense of belonging. Anna is clearly a shadow version of Akerman, a distanced film director who is equally unsure as to what she really wants from her life. In many ways, she becomes the marionette of her film producers, wandering in a daze through a variety of European cities, not quite sure as to why she is there.

Her life is a zoetrope of lifeless train stations, banal hotel rooms, late night cafes and the like. She fails at intimacy in almost every instance and, played over the backdrop of a reduced editing style brought over from Jeanne Dielman, the film captures the engulfing stasis of loneliness in all its silent grace.

The opening shot is almost a mission statement for this loneliness. A fixed image of a German train station shows a coldly symmetrical composition of the stairs leading down from the platform. We hear a train arriving though the camera refuses any break in the stasis. Huddles of people busily rush down the stairs, shuffling on to the next short moment of their lives.

One woman, our protagonist, begins to detach herself from this crowd, perhaps unwillingly and with little choice. She heads to a phone box but the camera still refuses to move: Akerman even denies her the company of the viewers themselves as she makes her call. She finally wanders back down the stairs which are deserted; her work (or perhaps her love life, it is uncertain in this instance) has separated her from everyone.

The film’s travelling is similar in tone to this scene, with a rigid inability to find any destination. Though she converses with fellow travellers on trains, Anna rarely takes anything in. So many of the conversations that float her way are one sided, allowing others to express and detail the problems they cannot otherwise share or be rid of. She becomes a key to unlock the frustrations of those around her on these tedious journeys, though she never ultimately resolves her own turmoil.

The journeying means she is never really there, never fixed, always clock-watching for the time of the next train or meeting. She is a phantasm of the city, never able to establish anything as the momentum of her work schedule drags her on, casting everyone around her to the wayside of the train lines.

Motherhood

A strange emotional haze is present throughout large parts of the film. The feeling finds a symbolic visual in Anna’s first hotel visit. The room she is staying in has large windows, covered with a thin, white curtain obscuring the view. Anna pulls it back and the camera follows her, creating a hypnotic image of a determined attempt to regain clarity. But behind the obscured image was only further evidence of how alone she is; how empty she feels on this meaningless meander back home. The emptiness gains greater specificity as the conversations between her and a variety of people amplifies her solitude.

When she visits Heinrich’s family, the conversation largely revolves around his own failed marriage, but the presence of both his mother and his daughter frames Anna in interesting ways. We barely see them converse, and Akerman skips the potential scene of them all eating together. Instead we hear of the dinner in hindsight, where Anna is then asked for her opinion of the two other women. It highlights Anna’s dual role as daughter and as a childless woman. The whole scenario cannot help but feel constructed to highlight her isolation and the parallel world she potentially could have inhabited as a mother herself.

In journeying back to her own mother, the distance becomes clear; that this is a rare occurrence for Anna, as if facing her mother highlights her own childlessness. The wandering journey of her films seem a failed searching for the children she never had, confirmed finally by her empty single flat in Paris at the film’s conclusion.

It also partly links to the muted sexuality of the character who is unable to fully commit to any one liaison or even bother to conclude any of them. In a later scene when her ex-lover begins to explain his own isolation, he professes his ideal world to be one where he is a woman who has one child, dedicating his life to it. It is as if every aspect of reality unconsciously derides Anna’s position. It speaks of a quiet, constant and very real social pressure.

Sexuality

Sex is icy in Akerman’s film though this is part of a continued trend from her early cinema. In Je Tu Il Elle, the daringly extended lesbian love scene is really one of the coldest sex scenes in 1970s cinema (contrary to its constant GIF-ified presence on websites like Tumblr and Twitter). The characters are so unsure about what they want that they resort to literally throwing their bodies clumsily towards one another in the hope of rekindling the romance that was once there.

Akerman employs the same effect in Les Rendez-vous d’Anna with the failed sex scene with Heinrich, the man similarly throwing his body at Anna, trying to evoke some reaction in return. But she remains passive, lifeless. Later on, with revisiting her ex-lover, the sexual tension of the scene similarly fizzles to nothing, with both characters instead enraptured by the vast city that lies outside of the window before the man becomes ill.

The only sexual satisfaction Anna has is in the past tense, recounting to her mother the moment she fell into bed with a woman in Italy, itself seemingly only by chance and not by design. The moment of this admission is unusual in that both Anna and her mother are themselves in bed, frozen and unsure how to react. It feels as if Anna is trying to explain to herself what happened and why she still phones the woman.

She professes love but it sounds hollow, with the overwhelming context of the film colouring it as yet another lost moment in a series of empty steps to nowhere. Sex is a strange performance no longer possible to repeat with total abandon when the knowledge of the people’s ultimate transience is a persistent spectre. There is nothing left but the self when cut loose from the emotional responsibility of others.

Ghostly Repetition

Akerman has a final, tragic trajectory for Anna. It is not simply the apartment she eventually finds herself in, cold, empty and with the lights off, but the answer machine that ghosts the lost moments of previous days when travelling.

A number of voices speak from the past through this machine. One is possibly the Italian woman she has been trying and failing to call at various points in her journey. Some are from friends, expressing a desire to meet, perhaps for more reasons than simply amiable company. But the most blunt is from her producer, suggesting that another such tour is about to come up, meaning more travelling. This time around it will be through various cities in Switzerland. It is a quietly brutal realisation of stolen agency: that Anna’s life is circular and really out of her hands.

But Anna’s journey has this shape because that is what constitutes loneliness; its never ending monotony, its lack of physical fixation. When Akerman addressed some of these issues in Jeanne Dielman, she did so by extending the length of shots, repeating household rituals and movements as Delphine Seyrig tried to normalise her own behaviour and isolation. In Les Rendez-vous d’Anna, Akerman has evolved and is looking at a different type of isolation.

Rather than being one whose illusion would collapse if the confines of the four walls of domesticity were broken, this loneliness dogs a woman across a whole continent, toying with the constant dissatisfaction that a hollow life ultimately leads to. It makes for what is surely one of Akerman’s strongest films but also one of her most honest; in which she faces head on the drifting reality of a creative life. Loneliness never felt so inevitable.

2 thoughts on “All The Lonely People

Leave a comment